Who is Blessed? A Response to Occupy Wall Street

I offered this service to my congregation this past Sunday, October 16, 2011. Special thanks to my amazing and wonderful nephew for his bravery in sharing his story with me.

I have included the prayer, the children’s story, the reading, and the benediction in addition to the sermon. If you just want to read the sermon, scroll down and you’ll get to it!


Today’s prayer is about blessings, and given that we are surrounded by diverse and sometimes competing understandings of what it means to offer and receive a blessing, and given that many of us have been hurt by the religion of our early years, and given that we are a unified people with diverse understandings of the ultimate, it would seem important to say a bit about what a blessing might mean in a Unitarian Universalist theological context. In our covenantal faith tradition, a blessing is always offered within the context of a relationship between the person being blessed and the person or persons offering the blessing. A blessing is about what we hope for someone or something that we give ultimate worth to. A blessing contains our highest hopes and dreams, and gives voice to the values that we wish would envelop this whole world. A blessing is about affirming and holding as high as w can our sacred connection to all of life, as manifested in the person before us or even in ourselves. So in the spirit of this holistic understanding of blessing, I invite you to join with me in prayer or meditation as you are willing and able:

Spirit of Life, source of all things, God or Goddess of ever expanding hope and light,

May that which created us from love and for love
heal and bless us – embracing us in the tenderest of mercies.

Many have sacrificed for us – long dead ancestors, parents, partners, children, dear friends, and others – so that we would have good fulfilling lives. They carried and sometimes still carry our deepest needs and desires as if they were their own and in this we have been so blessed. May our gratitude for these blessings and in turn bless those who blessed us.

We would also see as blessings those things that show us how frail we are. We need to give and receive forgiveness, we yearn to name those things that are unresolved, we hunger for reconciliation. May these difficult blessings awaken us, and perhaps in time, comfort and strengthen us, and restore us to trust and love.

May we find the blessing of peace in the love of those who surround us, understanding each others strengths and limitations, trusting in each other’s good intentions, so that once again we find in our midst a people and a place that we can call home.

May we bless our world in the spirit of hope, justice, and compassion. Amen and blessed be.

Story: “Lessons”  by Natalie Babbit in  “The Devil’s Other Storybook”



The Dueling Beatitudes – The Gospel of Matthew, Chapter 5 and amended version by Joe Abbey-Colborne

(These Beatitudes were blended together in a service at First Unitarian Dallas. Here is the video link where I found the reading. http://vimeo.com/19458107)

Blessed are the well off and those
…with ready answers for every spiritual question;
…they have it all.

Blessed are the poor in spirit for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.

Blessed are the comfortable;
…they shall avoid grief.

Blessed are those who mourn for they will be comforted.

Blessed are the self-sufficient;
…they wait for nothing, they have everything they want,
…and they have it now.

Blessed are the meek for they will inherit the earth.

Blessed are those who are not troubled by
…the injustice experienced by others;
…they are content with realistic expectations.

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness for they will be filled.

Blessed are the ones who gain the upper hand;
…they take full advantage of their advantages.

Blessed are the merciful for they receive mercy.

Blessed are those with a solid public image
…and a well hidden agenda;
…they are never exposed and see people
…in a way that suits their purposes.

Blessed are the pure in heart for they will see God.

Blessed are those who can bully others into agreement;
…they shall be called empire builders.

Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called the children of God.

Blessed are those who can point to someone else
…who is a worse person than they are,
…they will always look good by comparison.

Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness sake for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.

Blessed are they.


When I first heard about the movement called Occupy Wall Street, I’ll be honest and say I really didn’t pay much attention. I value those who are willing to take to the streets and make their voices and values heard. I’ve done it many times. But perhaps, like so many, I’ve grown disillusioned and cynical, quick to dismiss the ability of ordinary people to make big changes in their world. Even when I do choose to join a protest, I rarely expect any change. I go because I believe I must witness to my values, but I’ve really moderated my hopes as to what I can achieve. So when I heard there was this group taking to Wall Street with placards and slogans, protesting the growing inequality that has defined our society, I dismissed it as one more doomed attempt to change a very large system that seems pretty set in stone, and with the political machinery to maintain it.

It’s not surprising that it would be easier to dismiss a bunch of people camping out in some little park in New York City, than to hope that their commitment to sleep under the stars, dim as they are in New York City, and to brave the elements while shouting slogans and waving signs on behalf of the 99%, would add up to much.

Hope is a vulnerable thing. It is much safer to doubt and to criticize and to dismiss. Cynicism is a great way to protect ourselves from the possibility of being let down. In fact, many people who strongly agree with the political values of Occupy Wall Street dismissed the movement as a fly by night kind of thing. “It’s unorganized!” they said. “There is no core platform!” they proclaimed. “It will come to nothing.” Everyone was protecting themselves from the vulnerability of hope.

Interestingly, this is the same thing that was said of the Tea Party just two years ago. It was unorganized, with no core platform. It would go nowhere. Look at where the Tea Party is today. Granted, the Tea Party had corporate backing from the beginning. Occupy Wall Street is on the outside of that kind of power. Most truly progressive movements are. As Naomi Klein said in an interview on NPR this week, all Occupy Wall Street has is the power of bodies, which is why they are being so creative in resisting the many ways the authorities have tried to disperse the occupation. We saw that this weekend. Mayor Bloomberg announced that the park needed to be cleaned, and all understood what that meant. The Occupy Folks would be removed, and that would be the end of Occupy Wall Street. So what did they do? They got rubber gloves and soap and buckets, they cleaned up the trash and scrubbed the sidewalks! Mission accomplished!

So here we are, four weeks later, and Occupy Wall Street has occupied the news in growing measure day by day! Using the tools of social networking, livestreaming and online donations, it has drawn the support of millions from around the world. It also used the tools of the Arab Spring. Go to the Occupy Wall Street website and you will see that the organizers make a direct link between what happened in the Middle East and Northern Africa last spring, and what is happening now. The Arab Spring consisted of millions of mostly young people who took to the streets and just never went home. Their goal was democracy. They had little financial backing, just their bodies and their smartphones and their perseverance. They stayed in constant contact with the world through facebook, twitter and youtube. The Occupy Wall Street folks are not only copying their tactics, they are intentionally connecting the goals of the Arab Spring to their own. This is about freedom and democracy, which is really about equal and fair access to power and resources.

And now it’s growing. There’s Occupy St. Louis and Boston, Chicago and Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Diego and New Orleans. There have been Occupy marches in every state of this country. Internationally there are Occupy marches happening in Tokyo, Seoul, London, Paris, Manila, Berlin, Rome, Frankfurt, Toronto, Vancouver, Cologne, Munich, Vienna, Zurich, Madrid, Lisbon, Moscow, and Sydney, (I’m sure I’ve missed some) and last but not least, in almost every city of Greece, where many are taking to the streets as their country prepares for an orderly declaration of bankruptcy. Who is going to pay the price for Greece’s defaulting loans? The banks or the people? The people of the world have been watching our country and they know who paid the price and is still paying the price for the financial missteps of the 1% that led to the recession of 2008. It’s the 99%, and it is that fact that has propelled thousands of people onto the streets of cities around the world.

So I would have to say, that even in my usual cynicism, I’m getting a little hopeful! Now I know what happens in these protests. I’ve been to many. There’s always the hotheads, the ones looking for trouble, who goad the police, then get in trouble and scream police brutality. Happens at every march. We’re seeing a lot of that on the news of course because it’s a very convenient way to dismiss the other 99% who are standing there peacefully holding their little signs asking to be counted and valued. Those 99% are the true Occupy Wall Street, and this is where I am getting my hope.

My partner Laur and I got a call from our nephew this week. He’s just moved away for college to Easton Pennsylvania. This 18 year old millennial generation young man, fresh out of Springfield Missouri, got himself on a train to Lower Manhattan last weekend, and he found himself at Zucotti Park and spent the next three days there. It was an amazing experience. First of all, it’s very well organized. There’s a kitchen area, a medical tent, a charging area for cell phones and laptops, a clothing and blanket area, a communications area, and a teaching area.

One of the things he said to me was, “Look, I don’t even remember Clinton. I came of age during Bush, from 2000 to 2008, and I don’t remember any of us ever getting a break. Everyone was poor, everyone worked hard. Everyone was prudent and they still seem to struggle. And everyone pretty much kept quiet because no one was supposed to complain. So to see this, it was a breath of fresh air. We were all in this together. It was a community, the backbone of America, the 99%, and I wanted to be part of it.” As he spoke I wondered if Occupy Wall Street would be his generation’s Vietnam. There’s no telling yet.

Now most of you know that my partner and I don’t have kids. K. is the closest we’ve got, he is our pride and joy, and I’ve got to tell you this was the closest I have ever come to what it must feel like to be a proud Momma! I so want my nephew to have the opportunities he deserves. He’s got some strikes against him. Bi-racial, raised by a single mom, grew up in poverty. Even now at a private college where he got a full scholarship, the kids around him don’t bat an eye when they need something – clothing, toothpaste, books, sports equipment, an afternoon snack. He has to always be thinking ahead. He can’t take anything for granted. He wants a life where he doesn’t have to be so worried all the time about whether there’s enough to get to the end of the week. He doesn’t mind working hard, but he wants to know that his hard work will be rewarded with a living wage that isn’t going to decrease in value, has decent benefits, and will give him the ability to someday provide his children what they will need, so that they won’t struggle like he had to.

In my mind, this is what the Occupy Movement is about. It’s about dignified work that pays us what we’re worth. We are the 99%, our work is the backbone of this country, and it should be protected and valued and treasured. This movement is not about ending capitalism, it’s about ending crony capitalism. To use the words of Sally Kohn, a writer from Fox News, “The protesters are not anti-American radicals. They are the defenders of the American Dream, the decision from the birth of our nation that success should be determined by hard work not royal bloodlines.” http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/10/14/understanding-occupy-wall-street/#ixzz1awpZz7wF

It was much easier to be cynical and dismissive before K. went to New York, but after hearing his story, I started to care a lot more and it wasn’t just about having the courage to hope, but the moral imperative to hope. For our children’s sake, we have a moral imperative to hope. Hope isn’t a luxury, it’s a necessity, and I wonder if that’s what happens when you become a parent, you have to be willing to be vulnerable enough to hope. You owe it to your children.

In the preamble to today’s prayer and blessing, I talked about what a blessing means in Unitarian Universalism. A blessing is always offered in the context of a covenant, a sacred set of promises that is made between people. When we enter into lifetime partnerships, we are blessing each other. When we bring a new life into this world or adopt a new life into our presence, we are blessing each other. When someone makes the decision to enter into the covenant of membership, we are blessing each other.

The masses who flocked to the streets during the Arab Spring were blessing their countries with the inextinguishable hope for democracy. The Occupy Movement is, I think, searching for a blessing. It’s asking, who is blessed? Who gets the blessing? Is it the 1%? No one wants the 1% to give up their blessing, this is not about punishing the 1%, but about inviting them to share the blessing, to enter into a covenantal relationship of accountability and mutuality. This is what organizations like Patriotic Millionaires for Fiscal Strength are all about. They are calling for tax hikes on people like themselves because they are affirming their place in the covenant, and their desire to share the blessing within that covenant.

When Jesus stood on the Mount and offered the Beatitudes to the masses who followed him, he was talking about exactly that covenant, and he was being extremely and unabashedly political. Modern Christianity has often made the Beatitudes into little platitudes you can stamp on slabs of resin and hang in your bathroom. These words were and are a direct political challenge to the cynicism and disillusionment of his people. Occupy Wall Street camped outside Citibank yesterday, and Jesus stood outside of Jerusalem, facing the Romans, a most vicious empire that sucked its colonies dry. Roman culture made a religion out of brute strength and obsessive wealth accumulation at the upper levels of society. It often economically raped its colonies and used the plunder to line the pockets of the already wealthy. This economic rape plunged Israel into an economic depression the likes of which we can’t even understand. Farmers were evicted from their lands and hired back as cheap labor. The production of goods and services was ripped away from small Jewish businesses and given to Roman entrepreneurs. People who used to run their own businesses were then hired back as cheap labor. Unemployment skyrocked, and even for those who worked, economic independence was a thing of the past.

So for Jesus to stand there and say, “Blessed are the poor, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven,” dared them to hope.

Imagine what it meant to say, “Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted” to a family grieving the loss of land they had held for generations?

“Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they will be filled,” spoke to the physical and spiritual hunger for fairness and dignity.

“Blessed are the peacemakers,” challenged those who felt drawn to armed insurrection both as a form of divine retribution and a path to freedom. To use our children’s story, it’s like he was saying, “Don’t listen to the musician with the fiddle under his arm! That is not the music you should be dancing to. It will be simply another hell. Choose peace, and you will be blessed.”

For Jesus, the blessing didn’t just start in some mythical future time of complete justice and equality, it started in that moment. “You are blessed now!” he was saying, “So acknowledge your blessing, be filled with gratitude for it, and offer that blessing back to the world.” In other words, “Get off the pity pot, and live as if the kingdom of heaven on earth is already here.”

Jesus invited those who followed him into the vulnerability of hope, to turn away from cynicism and defeat and toward the willingness to take the risk of being disappointed, to witness like a parrot on a busy road, shouting out values that the fast moving traffic may not have been in any mood to hear.

And so now it’s those who flock to the Occupy Movement who stand on busy roads around the world, shouting slogans and waving placards that many of us are scared to look at and consider. Do we dare hope?

I don’t know about you, but I’ve shifted from dismissal and cynicism to hope. I think we owe it to our children. I think we owe it to ourselves.

Yesterday evening as Occupy Wall Street protesters lined up at Citibank to close their accounts, the police, at the request of Citibank, dragged them out into the streets, and just like in the Arab Spring, every blow was digitally captured. More than 5000 of us watched it on livestreaming, and I know that because you could see the numbers of viewers rise and fall. Those videos are now going viral over facebook and youtube.

I had to ponder the words of the beatitudes “Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.” I have to hope that this will make a difference, that we are being blessed by those who have the courage to speak and those who have the courage to listen.

May the blessings of the spirit be with you and yours, today, and forever more.

Amen and blessed be.

Go in peace.
Live simply, gently, at home in yourselves.
Act justly.
Speak justly.
Remember the depth of your own compassion.
Forget not your power in the days of your powerlessness.
Do not desire to be wealthier than your peers and stint not your hand of charity.
Practice forebearance.
Speak the truth, or speak not.
Take care of yourselves as bodies, for you are a good gift.
Crave peace for all the people in the world, beginning with yourselves, and go as you go with the dream of that peace alive in your heart.
Rev. Mark L. Belletini


About kristataves

I am a Unitarian Universalist minister serving the Unitarian Church of Quincy IL. St. Louis is my residence. I am a dual American and Canadian citizen living in the great state of Missouri and building my life in this wonderful and sometimes very frustrating state.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s